9 Easy Witch Hat Cookie Treats for Halloween Parties
Halloween parties aren’t about spooky costumes and scary movies. Let’s be real—it’s the snacks that steal the show.
And if you’re on treat duty this year, you can’t go wrong with witch hat cookies. They’re cute, simple, and look like you spent way more time than you actually did. (Pro tip: nobody has to know it took you ten minutes.)
I’ve baked witch hat cookies for three years. They vanish faster than the candy corn! Want to know the best part?
You don’t need to be a pro baker or own fancy tools: a few ingredients, a bit of creativity, and boom—you’re the Halloween hero.
Grab your mixing bowl (or a pack of Oreos—no judgment here).
Let’s go through 9 easy witch hat cookie treats that will wow your party crowd!
1. Classic Chocolate Witch Hat Cookies
Sometimes, the classics are unbeatable. These are the cookies you probably picture when you hear “witch hat treats.”
What you need:
- Fudge-striped cookies (flat side up)
- Hershey’s Kisses
- Orange or purple icing (piping bag or just a ziplock snipped at the corner works fine)
How to make it:
Pipe a small ring of icing in the center of the cookie, stick a Hershey’s Kiss on top, and you’ve got yourself a witch hat. Easy, fast, and ridiculously cute.
Why I love it: They take maybe five minutes. Seriously, you could make these during a Netflix commercial break (if anyone still watches live TV).
2. Oreo Witch Hat Cookies
Because let’s face it—Oreos make everything better.
What you need:
- Double Stuf Oreos
- Chocolate Kisses or Rolos
- Green or orange frosting
- Sprinkles for a little sparkle
How to make it:
Split the Oreo, use frosting as “glue,” then attach your candy on top. Add a sprinkle border if you want it to look extra magical.
Pro tip: The Double Stuf version works best. Not only do you get more icing (the best part IMO), but it also gives more stability to hold the candy hat topper.
3. Peanut Butter Cup Witch Hats
Want to add some peanut-buttery goodness to the party? These are the ones to make.
What you need:
- Mini Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups (unwrapped, obviously)
- Chocolate wafer cookies
- Brightly colored icing pens
How to make it:
Flip the peanut butter cup upside down on a cookie, then pipe icing around the base to look like the hatband. Done.
Why it works: Peanut butter + chocolate + Halloween theme = pure happiness.
4. Sugar Cone Witch Hats
Here’s where it gets fun—you’re actually shaping the whole hat.
What you need:
- Sugar cones (think ice cream cones, but pointy)
- Flat cookies as the base
- Melted chocolate for dipping
- Candy decorations
How to make it:
Dip the sugar cone in melted chocolate, place it upside down on the cookie, and decorate with icing and sprinkles.
Extra flair: Add edible glitter or gold sugar for a witchy glam effect. Because yes, even witches like sparkle.
5. Candy Corn Witch Hats
Candy corn might be controversial (you either love it or hate it), but you can’t deny it screams Halloween.
What you need:
- Chocolate cookies
- Hershey’s Kisses
- Orange icing
- A few candy corn pieces for trimming the base
How to make it:
Attach the Kiss with icing, then line the bottom with candy corn. It’s basically a witch hat in festive candy form.
Confession: I usually make extra of these because I “taste test” way too much candy corn while decorating. Oops.
6. Pretzel and Cookie Mini Witch Hats
Looking for salty-sweet? This is it.
What you need:
- Mini pretzels (round ones work best)
- Small cookies
- Melted chocolate
- Sprinkles or M&Ms for decoration
How to make it:
Dip the cookie in chocolate, set the pretzel on top as a hat rim, then stack a Hershey’s Kiss in the center. A little chaotic looking? Sure. But quirky is very on-brand for witches.
7. Marshmallow Witch Hats
These might not be the neatest, but they’re super fun for kids.
What you need:
- Jumbo marshmallows
- Chocolate for dipping
- Oreos or wafers as the base
- Icing for details
How to make it:
Dip the marshmallow in chocolate, plop it upside down on a cookie, and decorate. Add some candy eyes for a goofy twist if you’re feeling bold.
Heads up: Marshmallows slide a bit when dipped in chocolate, so maybe don’t make these right before guests arrive unless you want “melting witch hats.” 🙂
8. Witch Hat Cupcake Toppers
Okay, technically these are cupcake decorations, but trust me—they count.
What you need:
- Any cupcake flavor (chocolate is a safe bet)
- Frosting (black, green, or purple)
- Mini sugar cone hats
How to make it:
Frost your cupcake, stick a decorated sugar cone hat on top, and boom—you just leveled up plain cupcakes into a spooky showstopper.
Bonus points: Use black cupcake liners for an extra witchy vibe.
9. DIY Witch Hat Cookie Kit (Yes, It’s a Thing)
Not feeling like baking at all? You can actually buy Halloween cookie decorating kits on Amazon that include cookies, icing, and decorations.
Why it’s awesome:
- Zero effort required
- Great for kids or lazy adults (raises hand)
- Perfect activity for Halloween night if you don’t want to just hand out candy
Some of the top-rated cookie kits on Amazon include:
- Wilton Halloween Cookie Decorating Kit – comes with pre-baked cookies, colored icing, and sprinkles.
- Crafty Cooking Kits Witch Hat Cookies – a themed set that lets you make adorable witch hats without measuring a single ingredient.
Honestly, this is the route I went last year when time was tight, and people still thought I “baked.” Win-win.
Why Witch Hat Cookies Always Work at Halloween Parties
Let’s break it down. Witch hat cookies check all the boxes:
- They’re cheap – most recipes only need 2–3 ingredients.
- They’re fast – you can whip up a whole tray in under 20 minutes.
- They’re kid-friendly – little hands can help decorate without major disasters.
- They’re festive – nothing says Halloween like witches.
Plus, you can make them in bulk without stressing about oven space. I once made 50 cookies in under an hour (and ate way too many while “quality testing”).
My Personal Take
Out of all nine ideas, the sugar cone hats are my favorite. They just look so cool, and people always ask how I made them. But IMO, if you’re short on time, the classic Hershey’s Kiss on a fudge cookie is your safest bet. Zero stress, all the compliments.
And hey, if you’re not into kitchen chaos at all, those Amazon kits I mentioned are lifesavers. No shame in letting a kit do the heavy lifting. Your guests will never know. 😉
Final Bite
So there you go—9 easy witch hat cookie treats for Halloween parties that range from quick-and-done to full-on DIY creativity. Whether you’re hosting a big bash, sending treats to school, or just making something fun with your kids, these witch hat cookies will nail it.
Remember, Halloween is about having fun, not stressing in the kitchen. Keep it simple, make it festive, and maybe save a few cookies for yourself before your guests inhale them all.
Now, tell me—are you Team Classic Cookie or Team Sugar Cone?
Happy haunting (and happy snacking)! 🎃
