10 Unique Halloween Pizza Topping Ideas
So, you’ve got the costumes, you’ve strung up those not-so-scary spider webs, and you’ve stocked up on candy.
But let’s be real—Halloween parties aren’t about sugar highs and plastic vampire teeth.
They’re about food that makes people say, “Whoa, I did not expect that.” And nothing hits that sweet spot of spooky + delicious quite like Halloween-themed pizza.
Forget your everyday pepperoni situation. Here are some unique Halloween pizza topping ideas.
They’ll make your guests do a double take before they dig in! Sound fun? Yeah, I thought so. Let’s get cooking.
1. Spider Web Cheese Pizza
Want something creepy but also kid-friendly? Go for a spider web pizza.
Here’s the trick:
- Start with a basic pizza base and tomato sauce.
- Use string cheese or mozzarella strips to “draw” a web.
- For the spiders, slice black olives in half for bodies, then cut thin legs out of the remaining olives.
It’s equal parts spooky and adorable. Plus, kids won’t freak out since, well, it’s just cheese and olives. Ever notice how olives always get the creepy-crawly role at Halloween? Poor guys.
Pro tip: Grab a non-stick pizza pan (like the Wilton Perfect Results Pizza Pan on Amazon) to make sure your web doesn’t burn or stick. Nobody likes a crispy web unless it’s outside in October.
2. Jack-O’-Lantern Pepperoni Face
You know those pumpkin carving kits you buy and never actually use? Channel that energy into your pizza instead.
Use pepperoni or salami slices to create a pumpkin face design on top of your cheese pizza. Add jalapeño rings for eyes, maybe some bell peppers for a crooked grin. Boom—your pizza is now a jack-o’-lantern.
This one always gets a laugh, and IMO, it’s easier than carving an actual pumpkin. Plus, you can eat this one. Win-win.
3. Mummy Pizza Wraps
Tiny pizzas wrapped like mummies? Yes, please.
- Use mini naan breads or pita rounds as the base.
- Spread pizza sauce, then crisscross strips of mozzarella “bandages” on top.
- Pop in two olive slices for eyes.
Not only are these ridiculously cute, but they’re also the perfect snack-size bites for parties. You won’t even need a knife—just grab and go.
Party hack: Keep a pizza cutter wheel handy (the OXO Good Grips one on Amazon is solid) for slicing up extras quickly when your guests devour the first batch in five minutes.
4. Ghostly Mozzarella Toppers
Mozzarella is the unsung hero of Halloween pizza. Why? Because you can easily cut it into ghost shapes.
Get a ghost-shaped cookie cutter (yes, they exist), cut mozzarella slices, and lay them on top of your pizza. Dot two little “eyes” with black olives or peppercorns. Done.
It’s simple, spooky, and perfect for people who can’t handle the idea of “weird” toppings. Ever tried to get your uncle to eat anchovies? Exactly. Stick with ghosts.
5. Pumpkin-Shaped Pizzas
Why stick with circles when you can bake your pizza in the shape of a pumpkin?
Roll out your dough into a pumpkin outline (easy, since pumpkins are basically circles with stems). Then, use orange bell peppers, cheddar cheese, and pepperoni to give it a proper pumpkin glow.
Trust me, this one is Insta-worthy. Everyone will whip out their phones before they even take a bite. Because if you don’t post your pumpkin pizza, did Halloween even happen?
6. Monster Face Pizza
This one’s all about letting your imagination (and toppings) go wild.
Think:
- Red bell pepper tongues
- Olive slice eyes
- Mushroom eyebrows
- Jalapeño horns
Arrange them into goofy, scary, or downright weird monster faces. Let the kids join in—it’s basically edible arts and crafts.
FYI: If you’re serious about making these look sharp, get a stainless steel pizza knife for precise cuts (Amazon has some great budget-friendly options).
Because no one wants their monster face to turn into a “what even is that?” situation.
7. Bloody BBQ Chicken Pizza
Okay, this one’s for the adults who like their Halloween snacks a little extra.
Swap regular pizza sauce for deep red BBQ sauce (the thicker, the better). Toss shredded chicken on top, drizzle more sauce for that bloody effect, and finish with mozzarella “bones” (aka thin cheese sticks).
Is it dramatic? Absolutely. But Halloween’s basically the Olympics of dramatic food, right?
8. Eyeball Pizza Bites
Let’s be real: nothing screams Halloween like a plate full of eyeballs.
- Use mini bagels or English muffins as the base.
- Add pizza sauce and cheese.
- Place a slice of pepperoni in the middle.
- Top it with a green olive stuffed with pimento for that creepy “iris.”
And voilà—you’ve got eyeballs staring at you from the plate. Kinda gross, kinda fun, totally Halloween.
9. Candy Corn Pizza
Yes, I said it. Candy. Corn. Pizza.
Before you roll your eyes, hear me out. We’re not sprinkling actual candy corn (ew). Instead, mimic the look:
- Use mozzarella in the center.
- Add cheddar for the middle ring.
- Sprinkle orange bell peppers on the outer edge.
You end up with a pizza that looks like a giant slice of candy corn. It’s festive, colorful, and way less polarizing than the real candy corn.
10. Dessert Halloween Pizza
Sometimes you want sweet instead of savory. Enter: dessert pizza.
Spread Nutella or cream cheese frosting on a prebaked crust. Then, top with candy eyes, gummy worms, and crushed Oreos (for that “graveyard dirt” vibe).
Yes, it’s basically just an excuse to eat cookies on top of pizza dough—but honestly, who’s complaining?
Amazon tip: Use a ceramic pizza stone (like the Cast Elegance model) to get that crispy crust without burning the sweet toppings. Total game changer.
Why Halloween Pizza Works Every Time
Here’s the deal: pizza is already a crowd-pleaser. Dress it up with a little spooky creativity, and suddenly you’ve got a party centerpiece that everyone talks about.
Plus, unlike other complicated Halloween recipes (looking at you, Pinterest-fail cupcakes), pizza is forgiving. Cheese covers everything.
And let’s be honest: half the fun of Halloween is pretending to be spooky while secretly just wanting carbs.
Tools You’ll Want Handy
Since we’re talking toppings, let’s quickly chat about gear that makes your Halloween pizza night smoother:
- Pizza stone – for that crispy, restaurant-style crust.
- Pizza cutter wheel or knife – because butter knives are not it.
- Non-stick pizza pan – keeps your spooky designs intact.
- Cookie cutters – ghost, bat, or pumpkin shapes for toppings.
- Serving board – because presentation matters (Amazon has some gorgeous wooden pizza boards that double as serving trays).
Trust me, once you’ve got these basics, you’ll feel like a pizza pro.
Final Slice (See What I Did There?)
Halloween pizza isn’t about being perfect—it’s about having fun and making something people actually want to eat. From spider web cheese pizzas to dessert graveyard pies, there’s no shortage of ideas to make your night memorable.
So grab your dough, raid your toppings, and let your inner mad scientist loose in the kitchen.
And hey, if your jack-o’-lantern face ends up looking more like a melted potato, no worries. Pizza tastes amazing no matter what costume it’s wearing.
